An antitrust investigation has been filed in California against Google which alleges the company is taking advantage of its MADA (Mobile Application Distribution Agreements) which Android device manufacturers have to sign so the company can establish a mobile search monopoly.
The OEMs have to sign their MADA in order to include apps on their devices such as YouTube and Google Play (Books, Movies, Music .etc) applications. They must preload with Google apps and give them prominent locations – including Google Search.
Google Search must also be the default search engine on Android devices. Microsoft was forced to ensure users had the choice between which internet browser they wish to use on Windows 8 recently – and as a result the first start-up of a new machine gives the option to download competitors’ software.
“If device manufacturers bound by Google’s distribution agreements were free to choose a default search engine other than Google, the quality of Internet search overall would improve because search engines become more effective as they process more and more search queries,” the filing says. “With default search engine status providing access to more searches, Google’s competitors in search would become more effective as they processed more queries, and this competition would push Google to improve as well.”
“Also, if Google’s rivals were allowed to compete for default status, they would do so in part by offering to pay device manufacturers for that status on various Android smartphones and tablets. Such payments to device manufacturers, maximized by way of competitive bidding, would lower the bottom-line cost associated with production of the covered devices, which in turn would lead to lower consumer prices for smartphones and tablets,” the lawsuit says.
The lawsuit also cites Google’s agreement with Apple to ensure the search engine is the default option. This puts competitors such as Bing and Yahoo at a disadvantage.
The suit is seeking class action status, with plaintiffs also asking “that the Court award them and the proposed classes all appropriate relief, including, but not limited to, injunctive relief requiring that Google cease the practices effected by its MADAs as described herein, and declaratory relief, adjudging such practices unlawful, as well as monetary relief, whether by way of restitution or damages, including treble, multiple, or punitive restitution or damages where mandated by law or otherwise available, as well as recovery of their attorneys’ fees, costs, and expenses.”
Google had to face similar search monopoly investigations in the U.S and Europe without much repercussion. The lawsuit highlights these previous problems.
Do you think there’s a solid case over Google’s mobile search monopoly? Let us know in the comments.